Ripple vs SEC: Is the Case Closed? Judge’s Sign-Off Dispute Divides Crypto Community
The legal battle between Ripple and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has taken yet another twist, and this time, it’s not about price charts but about legal procedure.
A few days ago, reports surfaced claiming that SEC Gov v. Ripple was officially over after both parties filed a Joint Dismissal of the Appeals. Social media posts quickly went viral with the headline “The case is over.”
However, not everyone bought the news. Many in the crypto community dismissed the claims as premature or outright fake, leading to heated debates across X (formerly Twitter).
Analyst: “No Judge’s Signature Needed”
Crypto analyst Zach Rector weighed in, saying that under federal appellate court rules, both parties agreeing to dismiss an appeal doesn’t always require a judge’s sign-off.
SEC vs Ripple is done. No sign off from Judge needed.
— Zach Rector (@ZachRector7) August 11, 2025
"The general rule in federal appellate courts is that both parties agreeing to dismiss an appeal (stipulated dismissal) does not always require a judge to sign off on it, particularly if it's a straightforward dismissal."…
Rector pointed to Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure (FRAP) 42(b), which allows for a “stipulated dismissal,” meaning the circuit clerk can close the case if both parties sign an agreement, specify cost arrangements, and pay any required court fees.
In other words, if the appeal is being dropped with no extra requests, a judge’s approval isn’t mandatory.
When a Judge’s Order Becomes Necessary
Legal experts also clarified that if the dismissal agreement includes more than just ending the appeal, such as approving a settlement, reducing penalties, or vacating a lower court’s decision, a judge’s order is required.
Former SEC lawyer Marc Fagel addressed one of the community’s big questions: whether the supposed reduction in Ripple’s penalty (from $125 million to $50–$75 million) was true. Fagel confirmed it was not and Judge Torres had refused to lower the penalty, meaning Ripple will still pay the full $125 million ordered by the court.
Bottom Line: Appeals Dropped
If both Ripple and the SEC have agreed to drop the appeal without other conditions, the case at the appellate level is indeed over without a judge’s signature. But the penalty stands, and the dismissal doesn’t erase the original ruling or change the outcome on fines.
Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.
You may also like
AI trading cools down and storage chip competition intensifies, Korean stocks plunge over 5%, marking a second consecutive day of sharp decline; SK Hynix drops nearly 8%
On Tuesday, the Korea Composite Stock Index (KOSPI) dropped by as much as 5.1%, triggering the Sidecar circuit breaker mechanism on the exchange and suspending programmatic sell orders for five minutes. Both Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix fell more than 6%, marking five consecutive days of decline. Japan's SoftBank Group plunged over 8%, while AI industry-related stocks such as Tokyo Electron and Advantest also dropped by more than 5%.
Wall Street giants' financial reports tonight: With stock prices trapped in technical correction, even a 20% profit increase can hardly ease triple anxiety
Shares of major US banks hovered in a technical correction zone on Tuesday as the earnings season kicked off, with long-term borrowing costs rising to their highest levels in decades. This has heightened market attention on bank executives’ assessments of US consumer health and credit prospects.
UBS Earnings Season Preview: Strong Momentum from AI Spending, Favoring Lam Research (LRCX.US) and Texas Instruments (TXN.US), Remaining Cautious on Western Digital (WDC.US)
Lam Research (LRCX.US), Texas Instruments (TXN.US), and Western Digital (WDC.US) are set to release their quarterly earnings reports in the coming days. UBS believes that, with continued high spending on artificial intelligence, all three companies are likely to benefit from this trend.
Deutsche Bank (DB.US) upgrades AST (ASTS.US) rating: Has the SpaceX (SPCX.US) spectrum acquisition triggered an unjust sell-off?
Deutsche Bank has upgraded AST SpaceMobile to a "Buy" rating with a target price of $93. Despite stock price volatility triggered by SpaceX's spectrum acquisition, analysts believe that the cooperation potential with T-Mobile and government orders constitute core support. The recent short-term pullback may present a good opportunity to build positions.
Crypto prices
More
