Senate Democrats' DeFi legislative proposal draws fire from committee Republicans, crypto advocates
Quick Take Republicans need to get some Democrats’ support in the Senate to pass a market structure bill, experts say. Jake Chervinsky, chief legal officer at Variant Fund, called the Democrats’ proposal “unserious.”
A new proposal from Senate Democrats aimed at preventing illicit activity through decentralized finance is getting heat from many in the cryptocurrency industry and Republicans across the aisle.
On Thursday, Senate Banking Committee Democrats sent a proposal to Republicans on that committee, as reported by Punchbowl News' Brendan Pedersen and Crypto In America's Eleanor Terrett , aimed at regulating DeFi.
Some in the crypto industry were quick to criticize the proposal, calling it disappointing. Blockchain Association CEO Summer Mersinger warned that it would "effectively ban decentralized finance, wallet development and other applications."
"The language as written is impossible to comply with and would drive responsible development overseas," Mersinger said in a statement.
The six-page proposal, obtained by Politico, would designate the Treasury Department and other financial regulators to define when an entity or person "exercises control or sufficient influence." The Treasury Department would also decide whether a "protocol is sufficiently decentralized," according to that text.
Senate Banking Committee Democrats also proposed that any person or entity who "designs, deploys, controls, operates a front-end service for a DeFi protocol" or "materially benefits from a decentralized finance protocol that facilitates covered financial activities" would be considered an intermediary.
Different drafts
The Senate is working on its own legislation to regulate crypto market structure after the House passed its version this summer. The Senate Banking Committee's draft looks to allocate jurisdiction between the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission as well as create a new term for "ancillary assets" to clarify which cryptocurrencies are not securities.
A committee spokesperson said Republicans were "eager to work with Democrats on market structure," but noted Democrats had not committed to dates to debate the bill during a markup hearing. “What was sent to Republicans was not a legislative offer; the document was not written in legislative text, included multiple incoherent policy ideas, and was not a good-faith effort to engage on market structure," the spokesperson said in an email to The Block.
A spokesperson for Democrats on the Banking Committee did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Democrats on the committee previously set forth a framework that looked to "close regulatory gaps" and fold crypto issuers into a "regulatory framework."
Republicans need to get some Democrats' support in the Senate to pass a market structure bill. A final Senate bill would also need to be reconciled with the House's version. Meanwhile, the Senate Agriculture Committee, which has jurisdiction over the CFTC, has not yet released its version of the bill.
Jake Chervinsky, chief legal officer at the Variant Fund, called the Democrats' proposal "unserious," in a post on Thursday on X.
"These Senators claim to be pro-crypto, but what they propose is basically a crypto ban," Chervinsky said. "It's hard to imagine a good deal happening right now."
Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.
You may also like
U.S. chip stocks drop for eight consecutive sessions! $2 trillion wiped out in market value, marking the longest losing streak since 2008
This week, the investment prospects of AI were questioned by the market. The Philadelphia Semiconductor Index fell by 11.4%, and the Nasdaq dropped more than 4% in a single week. CoreWeave's stock price fell over 25% during the week, and its bonds dropped to distressed levels, casting doubt on the high-yield debt financing model. Strategists warned that being overly bearish could lead to missing opportunities, while "Wood Sister" bucked the trend and increased her holdings of CoreWeave.
In August, overseas funds returned to the U.S. Treasury market; UK holdings surpassed $1 trillion for the first time; Japan and China continued to reduce holdings, with China’s U.S. Treasury holdings hitting the lowest level since 2008
According to a report by the U.S. Treasury Department, overseas investors made net purchases of $108.9 billion in U.S. Treasury bonds in August, reversing a two-month decline in holdings. Among the top ten countries and regions holding U.S. debt, only China and Japan reduced their holdings in August. Japan, the largest holder, saw its holdings drop for the fourth consecutive month, reaching a 22-month low in the same month it intervened in the foreign exchange market. China’s holdings declined for the third straight month, hitting new lows for two consecutive months not seen since 2008. The UK, the second-largest holder, posted historic highs for two consecutive months. Canada recorded the largest increase in August, up $38.3 billion, ranking fifth overall. Belgium had the second-largest increase, up $19.8 billion.
Strategy surpasses JPMorgan in trading volume as MSTR neared 49M shares in August
Crypto prices
More
