Lawsuit Claims Satoshi Nakamoto’s Bitcoin Is Lost Property Worth Under $10 per Wallet
A lawsuit filed in New York County Supreme Court argues that Bitcoin wallets attributed to Satoshi Nakamoto should be classified as lost or abandoned property, with the complaint valuing each wallet at under $10.
What the lawsuit alleges about Satoshi’s Bitcoin
The case, filed by a pseudonymous plaintiff identified as “Noah Doe,” asks the court to recognize Satoshi Nakamoto’s dormant Bitcoin holdings as abandoned property under New York’s Abandoned Property Law (Article 7-B). The complaint targets wallets linked to the so-called “Patoshi pattern,” a set of early-mined blocks widely attributed to Bitcoin’s creator.
Court filings available through the New York State Courts Electronic Filing system show the complaint was lodged in New York County Supreme Court. The plaintiff is seeking a legal declaration that the wallets qualify as lost property, which could theoretically open a path to claiming custody.
Why the complaint values wallets at under $10 each
The sub-$10 valuation is the most unusual element of the filing. The complaint appears to distinguish between the value of the Bitcoin held inside a wallet and the value of the wallet itself as an abandoned container. Under this logic, a dormant wallet with no active owner has negligible standalone worth, regardless of the cryptocurrency it holds.
This framing attempts to exploit a gap between technical control and legal ownership. If the court were to accept that a wallet is worth under $10, abandoned property statutes designed for low-value lost items could potentially apply. A Galaxy Digital research analysis examined the legal theory, drawing parallels to historical abandoned property cases involving financial instruments.
The argument faces obvious skepticism. Courts would need to accept that a wallet holding an estimated 1.1 million BTC can be treated as a sub-$10 asset simply because no one has moved the coins since they were mined.
What this could mean for dormant Bitcoin wallets
If any part of this legal theory survives judicial scrutiny, it could set a precedent affecting millions of inactive crypto wallets. The outcome could reshape how courts treat long-idle cryptocurrency holdings, a question that matters as dormant Bitcoin supply continues to attract market attention.
The case also raises questions about how traditional property law applies to digital assets. Abandoned property statutes were written for bank accounts and safe deposit boxes, not cryptographic key pairs. As blockchain-based revenue models grow more complex, the legal frameworks governing on-chain assets face increasing pressure to adapt.
A core unresolved issue is whether inactivity alone proves abandonment. Bitcoin’s permissionless design means an owner can hold coins indefinitely without transacting, and courts have no established method for distinguishing a patient holder from someone who has lost access. This distinction is central to ongoing debates about crypto asset classification.
The lawsuit remains in its early stages. No hearing date has been publicly scheduled, and the court has not issued any preliminary rulings. The NYSCEF docket will be the first place to watch for motions to dismiss or any response from the state.
Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.
You may also like
To deliver computing power, Oracle uses trucks to transport natural gas to power its data centers
To address pipeline delays in AI data center construction, Oracle has adopted an unconventional energy supply method by transporting compressed natural gas via trucks, which has already been implemented in Utah and Texas, and is also being considered for the "Project Jupiter" in New Mexico. However, this solution costs four times as much as pipeline natural gas and is limited in scale, covering only a small fraction of the project's total capacity.
Aptos insider vesting ends, cutting APT unlocks by 60%
US Treasury yields soar to a 24-year high; US Treasury advisors expect future declines as AI investments and energy shocks drive up borrowing costs
David Zervos, senior advisor to U.S. Treasury Secretary Yellen and a veteran Wall Street professional, stated on Thursday that despite the recent surge in U.S. Treasury yields to their highest levels in decades, the current real yields are significantly elevated compared to historical levels, suggesting room for a decline in the future.
St. Louis Fed President: Further rate hikes needed over the next 6 to 9 months; inflation remains the top issue for the US economy
St. Louis Federal Reserve President Musalem said on Thursday that the Federal Reserve still needs to raise interest rates further in order to bring U.S. inflation back to the 2% target in a timely manner.
Crypto prices
More
