Bitget App
Trade smarter
Buy cryptoMarketsTradeFuturesStocksEarnInstitutionAI & More
Underperformed for 17 consecutive years! When will the commodity/stock super cycle emerge from the historical bottom?

Underperformed for 17 consecutive years! When will the commodity/stock super cycle emerge from the historical bottom?

华尔街见闻华尔街见闻2026/06/04 11:54
Show original
By:华尔街见闻

Since 2025, the commodities market has experienced one of the strongest rallies in recent years. Driven by Trump's tariffs on critical minerals, the Iran-Israel conflict, and the expansion of the AI industrial chain, prices of major commodities such as gold, silver, copper, and crude oil have all surged. However, from a relative valuation and historical perspective, commodities are still significantly undervalued compared to the S&P 500.

Currently, the ratio of the S&P GSCI Total Return Index to the S&P 500 Index is only 0.74, well below the long-term historical average of 3.87. Looking at the ten-year relative performance between commodities and stocks, there is a clear long-cycle pattern in history: from 1969 to 1980, stagflation and oil crises drove commodities to outperform equities; from 2000 to 2008, China’s industrialization and US dollar depreciation once again fueled a resource bull market. Since the 2008 financial crisis, however, commodities have trailed stocks for 17 consecutive years—a duration longer than most previous down cycles. Except for brief rebounds caused by the 2020 pandemic and supply shocks in 2025-2026, the relative performance of commodities against equities has long hovered at the bottom.

Underperformed for 17 consecutive years! When will the commodity/stock super cycle emerge from the historical bottom? image 0

At present, the real purchasing power of commodities relative to US equities is at its lowest point since 1970. The valuation disparity between physical and financial assets has never been so extreme. Yet, the underlying logic supporting a supercycle remains solid: there has been a long-term lack of capital expenditure in commodities and an investment backlog; supply is inelastic, and it is difficult for mining capacity to expand rapidly; demand for industrial metals driven by AI and energy transition remains structurally strong; and the long-term narrative of gold as an alternative to the creditworthiness of the dollar has not been substantially weakened.

However, the question remains whether the current commodities rally in 2025-2026 marks the beginning of a long-term bull market or just a short-term rebound lacking fundamental support. How much longer will commodities continue to linger at the bottom relative to US stocks?

Underperformed for 17 consecutive years! When will the commodity/stock super cycle emerge from the historical bottom? image 1

The Super Squeeze Changes Everything

What investors need to be wary of is that the current surge in commodities is more likely driven by an extreme supply shock—a "super squeeze": the prolonged closure of the Strait of Hormuz has resulted in approximately 14 million barrels of crude oil a day, a large volume of refined products, and a portion of Middle Eastern primary aluminum capacity being forced out of the global circulation network. As global energy supply tightens, resource nationalism is on the rise in nations that control key resources such as aluminum, nickel, and lithium, which are critical for the energy transition. Resource nationalism continues to rise at a time when global demand has not expanded in tandem.

Underperformed for 17 consecutive years! When will the commodity/stock super cycle emerge from the historical bottom? image 2

The key implication for investors is that commodities may be losing their independent cycle, reduced to being mere "puppets on a string" for US equities.

0
0

Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.

Understand the market, then trade.
Bitget offers one-stop trading for cryptocurrencies, stocks, and gold.
Trade now!

You may also like

Analysis - European Dilemma Provides New Reason for Dollar Bulls to Remain Optimistic

The US dollar has risen 5% against the euro, with some investors expecting further strengthening. The options market has become strongly bearish on the euro, as concerns over France’s fiscal situation and political uncertainty are creating pressure points for the eurozone. Laura Matthews/Saqib Iqbal Ahmed, Reuters New York, October 8 – This fall, the dollar surged to an 18-month high, with the latest rally fueled by uncertainty across the Atlantic, prompting some investors to bet the dollar will appreciate further. Analysts say the dollar continues to receive support from high—and possibly rising—US interest rates, robust economic growth, and persistent inflation risks. However, broader pressure centered on France’s massive fiscal deficit, potentially spreading to Italy and the wider eurozone, is emerging as a primary driver for the dollar in the coming months. So far this year, the dollar has appreciated about 5% against the euro, boosting the dollar index .DXY, which measures the dollar’s strength against six major currencies, including the euro (its largest component). “The euro remains under pressure, limiting one of the main alternatives to the dollar,” said Yuuto Shinohara, Senior Investment Strategist at Mesirow Currency Management. Last week, the yield spread between French and German 10-year government bonds recorded its largest weekly increase in decades, while the Italy-Germany yield spread saw its biggest weekly surge since the pandemic. The euro EUR= was last at 1.1183, down 0.67% against the dollar. “The market is focused on countries that, due to political dysfunction, cannot restore sustainable fiscal trajectories,” said Karl Schamotta, Chief Market Strategist at Toronto’s Corpay. One concern is that the euro no longer receives much support from the European Central Bank’s hawkish signals. The ECB raised rates by 25 basis points in September—its second hike this year to counter energy-driven inflation—but the euro fell after the decision, as markets worried about the impact of future hikes on the economy. Typically, rising European bond yields support the euro, but the euro's muted response suggests investors are increasingly concerned about growth and fiscal risks. Rising energy prices could add further pressure. “Structurally, Europe is a major energy importer and is more manufacturing-dependent than the US. The impact is obvious: high energy prices will drag down the region,” said Benjamin Ford, a researcher at Macro Hive. Ford expects the euro to fall to $1.10 within the next month, nearly 2% lower than current levels. “The US medium-term outlook seems stronger, while Europe is more susceptible to shocks,” Ford said. Policy Missteps Investors are also weighing whether the ECB can continue fighting inflation without causing greater harm to already weakening economies. The eurozone inflation rate (link) exceeded expectations in September, and with energy costs surging, it may rise further in coming months, keeping pressure on the ECB to hike rates. “There’s clear asymmetric downside risk for the euro at present,” said Dan Tobon, Citi’s Head of G10 FX Strategy in New York. “One of the likeliest triggers is policy error—if the ECB overtightens at a time when markets can’t bear it.” Euro risk reversal for one-month options, which measures whether traders are paying more to hedge against euro losses than gains, hit its most bearish level since March last Friday, while the three-month indicator touched its lowest point since June 2024. Federal Reserve policymakers have signaled that inflation risks remain high, which has helped keep US Treasury yields at multi-year highs. “Yields continue to rise, and US rates have an absolute advantage over most developed markets,” Shinohara said. Federal funds futures show about an 84% chance of at least one more 25-basis-point hike by December. Although few strategists expect the dollar to surge dramatically from current levels, they note that US economic resilience, sustained high yields, and Europe’s unique risks continue to tilt the balance toward the dollar. “For now, this imbalance looks very unfavorable for Europe,” Citi’s Tobon said. (For the convenience of non-native English speakers, Reuters automates translation of its reports into several other languages. As automated translation may be flawed or lack necessary context, Reuters does not guarantee the accuracy of such translations. They are provided solely for the readers’ convenience, and Reuters accepts no liability for any damage or loss arising from use of automated translation.)

路透社•2026/10/08 10:11
Analysis - European Dilemma Provides New Reason for Dollar Bulls to Remain Optimistic