Raw material shortages hinder magnet production, USA Rare Earth (USAR.US) downgraded by William Blair as key mineral sector weakens simultaneously
William Blair has downgraded USA Rare Earth (USAR.US) from "Outperform" to "Market Perform".
According to Zhihui Finance APP, William Blair has downgraded USA Rare Earth (USAR.US) from “Outperform” to “Market Perform”, without providing a price target, citing a series of recent challenges, including recent raw material shortages that are slowing down rare earth magnet production, despite the company “laying the groundwork for significant future upside.” USA Rare Earth shares plunged 12.62% on Monday.
William Blair analyst Neal Dingmann stated that, given raw material shortages will continue to affect subsidiary Less Common Metals, and subsequently the Stillwater magnet plant, he has significantly postponed USA Rare Earth's sales and margin estimates to 2028.
Dingmann pointed out that the Serra Verde project will eventually help ease raw material shortages, but under a 15-year take-or-pay offtake agreement, 100% of the first phase output of the project has already been committed to SIIE. SIIE is a special purpose vehicle backed by the Pentagon and funded by the US government, aimed at reducing America's dependence on foreign sources of critical minerals. As for the potential raw material support from the Round Top project, this will still take several years to be realized.
In addition, other business segments are facing operational challenges during ramp-up, and the rare earth segment faces event-driven risks. “Therefore, in the short term, we prefer companies with a longer history in materials processing,” Dingmann wrote.
This downgrade also seems to have affected other critical mineral stocks. Critical Metals (CRML.US) fell 14%, MP Materials (MP.US) dropped 6.9%, Rare Earth Americas (REA.US) declined 18.9%, Albemarle (ALB.US) dropped 5.7%, Sociedad Química y Minera de Chile (SQM.US) fell 4.6%, Lithium Americas (LAC.US) dropped 5.3%, Lithium Argentina (LAR.US) fell 5.4%, Standard Lithium (SLI.US) declined 4.4%, Sigma Lithium (SGML.US) fell 12.2%, Atlas Lithium (ATLX.US) dropped 5.2%, American Battery Technology (ABAT.US) declined 9.3%, and United States Antimony (UAMY.US) fell 13.6%.
Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.
You may also like
Circle issues 500 million USDC on the Solana network

Cardano vs Solana: Analysts and ADA Holders Clash Over Adoption

Ming-Chi Kuo: Google reduces next year's Broadcom-designed TPU shipments by 20% and plans to increase MediaTek's share
Renowned Apple and supply chain analyst Ming-Chi Kuo pointed out that Google has reduced the 2027 shipment volume of the TPU 8i series, designed by Broadcom, by about 1 million units, while planning to increase its procurement of the TPU 8t, designed by MediaTek. This move reflects that, limited by power and supply chain constraints, Google is prioritizing its computing resources towards the development of cutting-edge models.


